Proudly recognising

COTMA Achievement Awards

COTMA member museums achieve miracles — and that deserves recognition. Our awards set standards of achievement that peers can recognise, flag and be inspired to equal or better.

2025 Brisbane conference

This biennium's recipients

Top honour

The Bill Kingsley Award

Tramway Historical Society

Restoration of Christchurch Hills Car No. 24


The top scoring submission carries a certificate, a trophy and a cash prize of $500.

ACHIEVEMENT AWARD

Ballarat Tramway Museum

Providing an accessible tram — W7 1029

ACHIEVEMENT AWARD

Ballarat Tramway Museum

Providing an accessible tram — W7 1029

COTMA 2025 delegates at the Ipswich Rail Museum.
Individual recognition

Presidents & Volunteer Awards

Individual members of museums also deserve recognition — for work that has influenced, advanced or promoted tramway preservation beyond their own museum.

Presidents Awards

Awarded for an outstanding contribution by an individual over an extended period.

Richard Gilbert

In recognition of his active involvement with COTMA since its inception and his enduring commitment to the Ballarat Tramway Museum.

Volunteer Awards

Made on the recommendation of member museums.

Bill Allnutt

Perth Electric Tramway Society

Ray Blackmore

Perth Electric Tramway Society

Anthony Smith

Ballarat Tramway Museum

Vic Solomons

Sydney Tramway Museum

Michael Stukely

Perth Electric Tramway Society

John Tier

Wellington Tramway Museum

Basis of the awards

Not a competition — a standard

Achievement awards have been made since the 2000 biennial conference. They are not competitive; they exist to set standards of achievement that fellow peers can recognise and be inspired by. There may be any number of achievement awards at a conference.

In 2006 a formal EAR Award (Excellence and Recognition) was introduced for the most significant achievement. In 2014 it was retitled the Bill Kingsley Award, acknowledging Bill's outstanding service to the tramway museum cause, including his work establishing and developing COTMA.

2000

Awards established

Achievement awards first presented at the biennial conference.

2006

EAR Award introduced

A formal Excellence and Recognition award for the most significant achievement.

2014

Renamed for Bill Kingsley

The EAR Award becomes the Bill Kingsley Award, honouring Bill's service to the tramway museum cause.

Judging

Judging Four criteria, three judges

01

Degree of difficulty

The technical and logistical challenge the project presented.

02

Quality of outcome

Standard of workmanship and durability of the finished result.

03

Value to community

Benefit delivered to visitors, volunteers and the wider public.

04

Historical accuracy

Fidelity to original design, materials and operating practice.

Each criterion is scored out of 5 by three judges. High scoring projects receive an achievement award marked by a certificate; the top scoring submission wins the Bill Kingsley Award.

Submissions

How to nominate

Nominate

Achievement Awards

Give details of the achievement in no more than three A4 pages, plus photographs and any supporting documents you feel are relevant.


Post to: COTMA, PO Box 6172, Hawthorn West VIC 3122

Email: [email protected]

Nominate

Achievement Awards

Nominations should be no more than one A4 page and describe in detail the contribution your nominated volunteer has made.

  • Work a museum group deems significant, worthy of trans-Tasman recognition.
  • Work that has advanced or promoted preservation nationally or internationally.
  • Work superior to that already recognised at local museum level.

Email: [email protected]

Honouring our past

Previous Achievement Awards

Explore past recipients and the achievements that have been recognised for their contribution to preservation, restoration, innovation and the wider tramway museum community.

2023 - Auckland

2023 - Auckland

The Bill Kingsley Award

The judges were not able to separate two candidates for the Bill Kinglsey Award for Outstanding Achievement. Two Awards were made:

  • Ballarat Tramway Museum - for building a new Museum Interpretative Centre.
  • The Tramway Historical Society - for the Restoration and renewal of 1881 Kitson Tram No 7

Judges Comments


President's Awards

  • Graham Stewart - in recognition of his lifetime commitment to recording and photographing tramway systems in New Zealand since the late 1940s.
  • Dr John Radcliffe - in recognition of his service to COTMA as the inaugural President from 1975 to 1986 and ongoing contributions to COTMA and the recording of tramway history.

Certificate of Appreciation

Presented to Warren Doubleday in recognition of his long and ongoing commitment to COTMA including holding the position of President from 2002 to 2012.


Volunteer Awards

  • Virginia Fenelon and Pamela Waugh of the Ballarat Tramway Museum
  • Noel Blackmore, Nick Tsiaglis, Trevor Dennhardt, Terry Young and Stuart Darbyshire of Perth Electric Tramway Society.

2021 - Awards only - COVID era

The Bill Kingsley Award

  • Wellington Tramway Museum for the restoration to running order of Wellington Tramcar 17.

Submission Details

Judges Comments


Recognition Award

  • The Tramway Historical Society for the renewal of Restaurant Tram 411.

President's Awards

  • Warrington Cameron for Geelong Duncan and Fraser Car No. 2.

Certificate of Appreciation

  • Presented to Warren Doubleday in recognition of his long and ongoing commitment to COTMA including holding the position of President from 2002 to 2012.

Volunteer Awards

  • Chris Bennett and Colin Seymour of the Australian Electric Traction Museum, Adelaide.
  • Bill Allnutt, Ian Kelly, Stuart Darbyshire and Ian Sidebottomm of the Perth Electric tramway Society.
  • Brian Andrew and Larry Day of the Tramway Historical Society - Christchurch.
  • Keith McGavin of the Wellington Tramway Museum.
2018 - Perth

The Bill Kingsley Award

  • Perth Electric Tramway Society - for the restoration of for the restoration to full operation of E class Perth Tramcar No. 66.

Achievement Award

For the cooperative work across many years enabling the continued commercial Service of Sydney R class tram 1808, now running as Christchurch 1888.

The award was shared between the volunteer-based organisations of:

  • Sydney Tramway Museum as owner of the car,
  • Western Springs Tramway Auckland
  • Tramway Historical Society (Christchurch) on behalf of the Heritage Tramways Trust
  • Christchurch Tramway Ltd in developing a continued use for the car.

(opens in new tab)

Award Presentation and Judges Comments


Chairman's Awards

  • Wellington Tramway Museum - for their commitment to purchasing at considerable expense, all of the available overhead fittings and parts arising from the closure of the Wellington trolley bus system. These are available for distribution across the world to museum tramway and trolley bus organisations.
  • James Duncan (Auckland) - high commendation for the often heroic effort he has put in attempting to keep the struggling Dockline Tramline operating and for his ability to rally others to the cause.

2016 - Christchurch

The Bill Kingsley Award

Tramway Historical Society (Christchurch NZ) for the restoration of Dunedin Mornington Cable Car Trailer 111.

Award Presentation and Judges Comments


Achievement Awards

  • Ballarat Tramway Museum - Installation of a Solar Power Supply System
  • Ballarat Tramway Museum - Cuthberts939 - Function Tram.
  • Wellington Tramway Museum - Restoration of Wellington Fiducia 260.

Volunteer Awards

  • Roger Gosney and Peter Waugh of the Ballarat Tramway Museum
  • Murray Sanders of the Tramway Historical Society
  • Gus Weir of the Wellington Tramway Museum

2014 Sydney

2014 Sydney

The Bill Kingsley Award

  • Tramway Historical Society (Christchurch NZ) for the restoration of Invercargill City Tramways Birney No. 15

Award Submission


Achievement Awards

  • Western Springs Tramway - Restoration of Melbourne SW6 906.

Volunteer Awards

  • Roger Salen and Gavin Young of the Ballarat Tramway Museum.

2012 Adelaide

2012 Adelaide

EAR Award

  • Perth Electric Tramway Society (PETS) for their book "Tracks by the Swan – The Electric Tram and Trolley Bus era of Perth, Western Australia."

2010 - Wellington

2010 - Wellington

EAR Award

  • Ballarat Tramway Museum
  • Western Springs Tramway

Achievement Awards

  • Australian Electric Traction Museum - Restoration of Bogie Open Combination tram 118.
  • Ballarat Tramway Museum - Community Partnership - Horse Tram Operations.
  • Tramway Historical Society - Christchurch Tramway Board Electric Tram No. 26.
  • Western Springs Tramway - Wellington Double Decker Tram No. 47 "Big Ben".

2008 - Launceston

2008 - Launceston

Achievement Awards

  • Wellington Tramway Museum - Conservation Plan for Wellington Electric Tramway No. 17.
  • Melbourne Tramcar Preservation Association -The Preservation and Restoration of MMTB L class tram No. 103.

2006 - Melbourne

2006 - Melbourne

EAR Award

  • Melbourne Tramcar Preservation Association - Preservation and Restoration of tramcar VR No. 41.

Achievement Awards

  • Ballarat Tramway Museum - "Meeting Challenges" - Rebuilding the electrical sub-station and publishing "The Golden City and its Tramways"
  • Melbourne Tramcar Preservation Association - Preservation and Restoration of VR No. 41
  • Wellington Cable Car Museum - Restoration and display of Cable Grip Car No. 3.

2004 - Auckland

2004 - Auckland

Achievement Awards

  • Australian Electric Tramway Museum – Northern Depot and Administration Building
  • Ballarat Tramway Museum – Ballarat Begonia Festival 2004 – “Moving People”
  • Perth Electric Tramway Society – Mainline Re-sleepering Project
  • 1912 Boon Tram for Wanganui Society – Conservation Plan for Electric Tram No. 12.

 

2002 - Rockhampton & Brisbane

2002 - Rockhampton & Brisbane

Achievement Awards

  • Omnibus Society - Restoration of NZR Omnibus 3583
  • Steam Tram & Railway Preservation Society - Recommencement of Regular Museum Operations at Valley Heights
  • Ballarat Tramway Museum - The Ballarat Gold Tram Marketing Project
  • Portland Cable Trams - Construction & Opening of the Portland Cable Tram Project
  • Sydney Tramway Museum - 50 years of Trolley Wire
2000 - Ballarat

2000 - Ballarat

Achievement Awards

  • Australian Electric Tramway Museum – Refurbishment of Glenelg 360
  • Museum of Transport and Technology - The MOTAT Act 2000
  • Tramway Historical Society - Restoration of CTB No. 1